Update Cepat • Informasi Akurat • 24 Jam
Wednesday, 18 November 2026
Breaking
Beranda›Uncategorized
Uncategorized

Why Lim’s Proposal Undermines the Concept of ASEAN Cooperation

Why Lim’s Proposal Undermines the Concept of ASEAN Cooperation Lim Guan Eng’s statement urging Indonesia to compensate Malaysia for the impact of transboundary haze […]

Why Lim’s Proposal Undermines the Concept of ASEAN Cooperation

Lim Guan Eng’s statement urging Indonesia to compensate Malaysia for the impact of transboundary haze or allow the establishment of a regional firefighting force with the authority to enter Indonesian forest areas reflects a problematic understanding of contemporary interstate relations. Lim raises a legitimate concern. Transboundary haze has affected public health, economic activities, education, and the daily lives of people across several Southeast Asian countries. Indonesia cannot disregard these consequences. However, the more fundamental question is why his proposed solutions revert to compensation and pressure on national sovereignty, when the underlying causes increasingly involve environmental governance, corporate interests, and cross-border investment networks.

In contemporary international relations, ecological disasters can no longer be understood rigidly as purely domestic matters confined within the territorial boundaries of individual states. Environmental degradation, climate change, forest fires, air pollution, and public health crises have transboundary characteristics. Their consequences do not follow national borders. Addressing them therefore requires a regional approach that goes beyond traditional diplomacy based on bilateral relations and demands for financial compensation.

Recognizing the transboundary nature of such disasters, however, does not mean that national sovereignty should be disregarded. Modern regionalism requires states to manage shared interests through institutions, policy coordination, information exchange, and mutually agreed accountability mechanisms. In other words, sovereignty need not become an obstacle to cooperation, but neither should it be used to legitimise unilateral actions by other states.

Moving Beyond the Logic of Compensation and Coercion

Lim Guan Eng’s proposal essentially presents Indonesia with two options: pay compensation for Malaysia’s losses or grant a regional firefighting force access to Indonesian forest areas to conduct operations. Both options reflect an approach that is transactional and potentially coercive. A complex ecological problem is treated as though it could be resolved through a financial payment or by granting foreign actors operational authority.

This approach overlooks far more fundamental questions: who benefits economically from activities that increase fire risks? Who controls the concessions? Who provides the financing? Who manages the supply chains? And who should be held accountable when environmental damage occurs?

Compensation can certainly serve as a legal instrument for remedying losses when liability and causation have been established. However, making financial compensation the primary solution without first identifying the responsible actors and the mechanisms that caused the damage fails to address the root of the problem. The state should not be the only party bearing responsibility for damage that may involve corporations, concession holders, investors, and transnational business networks.

Even more problematic is the proposal to establish a regional force with the authority to enter Indonesian forest areas. International firefighting assistance should certainly be welcomed and strengthened when Indonesia requires it. However, assistance provided with the consent of the receiving state is fundamentally different from granting foreign forces the authority to enter another country’s territory. The former constitutes regional cooperation, while the latter risks establishing a precedent for intervention in national jurisdiction.

Regional solutions should not be built on ultimatums. If every transboundary problem is addressed through threats of compensation or demands for unilateral access, ASEAN will move further away from institutional cooperation and return to a politics of interstate coercion. In this respect, Lim’s approach resembles a logic of compulsion rather than mature regional diplomacy.

Why Corporate Accountability Must Be at the Centre of the Debate

An important dimension largely overlooked in Lim’s argument is the involvement of corporations and transnational capital networks in regional land and forest governance. Forest and land fires cannot be explained solely through relations between the Indonesian government and neighboring countries affected by haze. Plantation activities, forestry industries, land clearing, peatland management, and commodity supply chains must also form a central part of the analysis.

A report released by Greenpeace Indonesia and Greenpeace Malaysia in November 2026 identified 17,390 smoke-source hotspots in Indonesia between 8 August and 31 October 2026. Of these, 1,776 hotspots were detected within 46 oil palm plantation concessions, while another 2,586 were located within 28 industrial timber plantation concessions. The report also identified more than 40 palm oil and forestry companies with links to companies or business groups in Singapore and Malaysia.

These findings do not, by themselves, prove that every company identified engaged in burning or bears legal responsibility for the fires. Nevertheless, the data demonstrate that the haze problem has a corporate and cross-border investment dimension that cannot be ignored. The relationships between concession ownership, investment, financing, and supply chains must be examined transparently to ensure that accountability does not stop at the jurisdictional boundaries of the country where the fires occur.

This is where a fundamental weakness in Lim’s approach becomes apparent. He demands that Indonesia compensate Malaysia for its losses, but fails to place corporate responsibility and transnational business networks at the center of the proposed solution. Yet, if companies operating in or benefiting from land use in Indonesia have ownership, financing, or supply-chain links with entities in Malaysia and Singapore, the governments of those countries also have a role to play in ensuring that companies under their respective jurisdictions fulfil their environmental responsibilities.

Environmental accountability should not stop at the borders of the country where the damage occurs. It should follow the structures of ownership, financing, corporate control, and supply chains that enable such economic activities to take place. Corporations should not be allowed to enjoy the benefits of cross-border operations while evading accountability when their activities generate ecological risks.

This approach is far more relevant than simply demanding that Indonesia pay compensation or open its territory to foreign firefighting forces. The central issue is not merely how to extinguish fires, but how to prevent economic interests that generate fire risks from continuing to operate without adequate oversight and accountability.

Modern Regionalism Is About Shared Governance, Not Intervention

From the perspective of modern regionalism, ASEAN cooperation should move beyond diplomatic coordination towards more effective governance of shared regional problems. Regionalism should no longer be measured merely by the number of meetings, joint statements, or normative agreements. Its success must be reflected in the ability of member states to establish mechanisms for prevention, information sharing, investigation, and accountability for actors operating across national borders.

ASEAN already has an institutional foundation through the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, signed in 2002 and ratified by Indonesia through Law No. 26 of 2014. The agreement places prevention, monitoring, mitigation, and regional cooperation among the responsibilities of member states. The principal challenge is not simply the absence of a regional framework, but the gap between regional commitments and policy implementation at the national level.

Developments in Indonesia-Singapore cooperation in October 2026 demonstrate that a more constructive approach is already emerging. The two countries established a joint task force to coordinate information and investigations into companies linked to forest and land fires. Singaporean Prime Minister Lawrence Wong subsequently proposed expanding this platform into a mechanism covering all ASEAN member states.

Such a model offers far greater potential. Member states can share hotspot data, concession maps, corporate ownership information, investment records, and evidence of land-clearing activities. They can also develop firefighting assistance protocols, strengthen corporate oversight, and coordinate law enforcement within their respective jurisdictions. Personnel and firefighting equipment can be deployed on the basis of requests and consent from the state requiring assistance.

Under this approach, sovereignty is not treated as a barrier to cooperation, but as the foundation upon which states fulfil their responsibilities collectively. Indonesia retains jurisdiction over its territory, while neighboring countries gain legitimate opportunities to participate in preventing and addressing transboundary impacts.

Modern regionalism should develop the principles of shared responsibility and corporate accountability, rather than replace them with the logic that the state from which pollution originates must pay compensation or accept intervention. Shared responsibility does not mean diluted responsibility. On the contrary, each actor must be held accountable in accordance with its contribution, authority, and capacity.

Prabowo’s Apology: A Diplomatic Gesture, Not an Admission of Legal Liability

Lim’s statement also reveals a misunderstanding of the significance of President Prabowo Subianto’s apology to Malaysia and Singapore. Lim suggested that Malaysia should accept the apology in the spirit of good neighborly relations and ASEAN solidarity. However, it is important to understand that a head of state’s apology in a diplomatic context does not automatically constitute an admission of legal wrongdoing or acceptance of an obligation to pay compensation.

In Indonesia’s diplomatic tradition, courtesy, respect, and hospitality are important elements of building relations with other countries. An expression of regret over the inconvenience experienced by neighboring populations can be understood as a gesture of empathy and a leader’s moral responsibility. Such a gesture does not necessarily imply that every loss claimed by another party is legally attributable to the Indonesian state.

This distinction matters. In international relations, diplomatic expressions, political responsibility, and the legal admission of liability are separate matters. They cannot simply be treated as interchangeable. Establishing legal responsibility requires evidence of the relevant conduct, causation, damage, and applicable legal grounds.

Prabowo’s apology should therefore be understood primarily as a diplomatic gesture and an expression of respect for neighboring countries, not as a blank cheque for compensation claims. Indonesia can demonstrate empathy towards the people of Malaysia and Singapore without automatically accepting every claimed figure or demand before it has undergone proper scrutiny and verification.

Equating diplomatic courtesy with an admission of legal liability risks narrowing the space for diplomacy. A national leader should be able to express empathy without compromising the country’s legal position and national interests.

ASEAN Needs More Civilized and Forward-Looking Solutions

Criticism of Indonesia over the haze problem should not be dismissed. Indonesia must improve forest and land governance, strengthen fire prevention, enforce the law against companies proven to have violated environmental regulations, and increase the transparency of environmental data. The government should also welcome necessary regional assistance and remain open to cooperation based on mutual agreement.

However, neighboring countries must also develop a more consistent approach. If companies with links to Malaysian or Singaporean capital and business groups are proven to have contributed to fires, those companies should be investigated and held accountable through relevant legal mechanisms. It is unfair for the country where the concessions are located to remain the sole target of pressure while the ownership structures, financing arrangements, and corporate beneficiaries operating across national borders escape serious scrutiny.

ASEAN needs to move towards a more advanced system of regional ecological governance. Its mechanisms could include a joint fire-monitoring system, disclosure of concession maps and ultimate beneficial ownership, cross-border investigations, evidence-sharing arrangements, common fire-prevention standards, and firefighting assistance based on the consent of the receiving state. Member states must also ensure that companies operating across jurisdictions cannot exploit regulatory differences to evade responsibility.

Such an approach is far more civilized, rational, and forward-looking than threats of compensation or demands for another country to open its territory to foreign forces. It does not disregard the suffering of affected communities, but neither does it use that suffering as a justification for disregarding legal principles and sovereignty.

Ultimately, haze pollution is not merely an issue between Indonesia and Malaysia. It is a test of ASEAN’s ability to evolve from an organization centered on consultation and non-interference into a regional community capable of managing shared risks effectively. Sovereignty remains important, but modern sovereignty must also be accompanied by responsibility towards the environment and people across national borders.

Lim Guan Eng is right that recurring haze pollution must not continue without accountability. However, he is mistaken in making compensation and foreign military-style access the primary options for resolving the problem. The solution for the future is not to force Indonesia to pay or surrender authority over its territory. It is to build a regional system capable of identifying perpetrators, tracing capital flows, monitoring corporations, preventing fires, and protecting communities.

ASEAN does not need coercive politics that revive the logic of interstate compulsion. It needs mature regionalism that places shared responsibility, corporate accountability, respect for sovereignty, and human protection at the foundation of ecological crisis management.

Tentang Penulis

adminmedia24

Jurnalis MediaUpdate24 yang menyajikan informasi aktual, ringkas, dan relevan untuk pembaca.